1. How To Subdue A Major Internet Corporation

    Almost two weeks ago I came to have some trouble with the knowldgeable work of some Yahoo!/Flickr support employee. For those of you, that actually haven’t heard of it until now: You can read through the whole story here.

    The kind and mass of attention, was something I haven’t had to deal with before, so the first week was kind of exhausting to me. Furthermore the majority of media involved was based in the Us with a 6-10 hour time diffenrece, keeping me up until 3 a.m. to answer questions, emails and comments. Not to mention I still had to work during day time.

    In one of my comments I lightly made a joke ,that now, after havng succeeded in my quest I could write a short manual on how to actually get your Flickr account back after it has been dleted by accident or some dubious reason. To be quite honest, I believe the accident part helped me a lot  in getting this volume of media attention, since I couldn’t have possibly done anything wrong in this case and already had received an apology from Flickr for this incident.

    I’m not totally sure this is reproducable with Yahoo! or any other company, but here’s a small summary of what happened from my perspective.

    Tuesday

    After returning from work I started my routine email and web check, which includes reading through new comments on my Flickr account. I had to login with my yahoo account, so I first guessed the cookie had expired… until I was asked to create a new Flickr account as well. I typed in my own account which was already taken. Opening the public profile page revealed to me that my account had indeed been deleted.

    I had been in contac with Flickr support on Friday, after I had been added as buddy by someone collecting all kinds of Lamborghini pictures in his account, that clearly weren’t his own. So to prevent him from also taking my photos I blocked him and send a short report to Flickr (bad mistake, actually).

    My first though was: “Maybe they just mixed up the two accounts” and so I wrote a short email reply to the supporter that accepted the report

    Hello,

    Unfortunately, I have mixed up the accounts and accidentally deleted yours. I am terribly sorry for this grave error and hope that this mistake can be reconciled.

    Here is what I can do from here:

    I can restore your account, although we will not be able to retrieve your photos. I know that there is a lot of history on your account—again, please accept my apology for my negligence. Once I restore your account, I will add four years of free Pro to make up for my error.

    Please let me know if there’s anything else I can do.

    Again, I am deeply sorry for this mistake.

    Regards,
    Flickr staff

    Ok, so I’d been right, they screwed up… big time. At the time I believed to have around 3900 photos in there, not all of them public. No problem, since I always just uploaded small versions of my pictures to Flickr, keeping all the files at home.

    But: Most of the public photos had been linked by various blogs, websites and some magazines. This was trouble, since I’ve been working for years to curate this account and generating a constand stream of visitors each day. With the account actually gone I’d have to start from scratch again.

    But, I’m not the one to sit down and start crying, If I’m still able to stand up and kick someone in the balls.

    The weapon of Choice: Posterous

    For a very obvious reason. I configured Posterous to be a publishing hub. Everything I send here ends up in Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr and Soup.io is aggregated in various RSS feeds by some international outlets and combined I can reach a few thousand people without being forwarded.

    This is something I couldn’t get from my “normal” private blogs since they have specific topics and don’t draw as much of a crowd.

    The Result: You have to be fucking kidding, Yahoo!

    Words of advise: If you’re f***ing mad about something and you want people to know, spell it out. It helps creating an interest in what you want to tell. 57,000+ readers and 150 Tweet forwards can’t be that wrong.

    I now had the information out, but that still isn’t enough. You need someone with influence to adress people you don’t even know yet. I knew of Thomas Hawk for a few years now. He’s a US photographer with a reputation of sticking his fingers where it really hurts, especially when it’s about Flickr.

    Luckily he was on twitter posting something similar, so I could easily answer him and attach the link to my text to the post. … And within an hour all hell broke loose, at least I thought so. I was suddenly mentioned multiple times on the Flickr help forum, the New York Observer asked for additional information and made this into multiple stories, including a short photogallery, during the next days. Over night newspapers and blogs from all over the world picked up on this story. But I should only find out about this on the next morning.

    Wednesday

    Three hours of sleep simply aren’t enough. I was tired, my mailbox was overflowing, but I still had to go to work. To make thing worse I had to go to Bern and catch a Train at 8:00 a.m. … well I was too tired and missed it, so I took the one at 9:00 a.m.

    My iPhone kept pinging with new emails every few seconds and this didn’t stop the whole day. I told my manager about the situation. After all I couldn’t actually focus on much besides the meetings I had to attend the the emails coming in, and the call from the local newspaper for a statement on what happened.

    In the evening I sat down to get an overview of the news about my case and wrote a small summary. By now Flickr was actually working on getting my account back. This actually was the most surprising information I got that day. But I guess, If you have The New York Observer, CNN, The LA Times, TechCrunch and other major new outlet on your bad PR count everything that help getting out of this kind of news is suddenly possible.

    On one of the websites, I found that day they had a small chart with web mentions of word “Yahoo”. It had a sudden 25% increase on Tuesday night. I’ve looked at this chart and couldn’t think of how my little problem may have led to this result. But if it was telling the truth and that actually made Yahoo/Flickr move off their previous “sorry, but who cares” policy it had been good enough for me.

    Later that night I could see parts of my account being functional again. Well, in the way, that all of the public photos where brought and the links started working again. Some of the text contents had gone due to using the wrong format, but that wasn’t that important at the moment. I received the info, that I will get access as soon as all the rebuild account data had been checked.

    Thursday

    By now, half the company knew what had happened… as long as they’d read the morning news. The good news was, although I had to get to Bern again, this time we were car pooling and I didn’t have to get up that early.

    Today I only had to make some final statements to a few newspapers about the state of the reconstructed account. I reserved the comments and emails for Friday, since we had a company party event that evening.

    Friday

    After almost a week without much sleep I really needed that extra strong espresso at the office. But it didn’t help much, so I went home earlier that usual. the Flickr account was working again … mostly, and all of the pictures, descriptions and comments had returned.

    The downside being, that my pictures still remember being in different groups, that had thrown them out after they weren’t available anymore. I can’t fix this, since I cannot tell the photos to remove themselfs from the groups without ending with some error messages. Using the Organize feature isn’t helping either. Since nothing works here. Groups are empty and my sets produce error messages preventing me to edit them.

    Sounds like another email to the support staff.

    Monday

    Someone fixed the problem with the Organize feature over the weekend. This acually very good news. I still have the group issue, but that’s not as important at the moment.

    After all: I achieve something, nobody did in the past. I actually got my Flickr account restored. The buzz and pressure on Yahoo for some reached such a level this time, they had to openly anounce that it is possible to restore account data and that they will roll out this feature later this year!

    … oh.. and the gave me a free 25 years of Flickr Pro subscription.

    Not that I would have paid a Dollar for any of their services again in the future, but there is still no viable alternative to Flickr on the internet.

    Posted via email from bindermichious | Comment »

  2. Flickr Fallout - 5 Days Later

    So far it’s still looking good.

    Yesterday I could reconnect Flickr to my Yahoo! account and everything seems to be there.

    Until now, I only noticed one minor glitch: I can’t reorganize existing picture sets. Loading them in the Organize tab will only display an error message without loading the content of the set. As soon as I add a news photo the set counter begins at 1 again.

    Community groups also do show some strange behavior. I can see the group membership on the photopage but the groups themselves had already removed the dead links during this week. My guess is, I’ll have to remove and add the pictures again from the photopage.

    yesterday Thomas Hawk send me link to a little collage, he’d collected from the Flickr Help Forum

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/thomashawk/5416699710/ (CC-BY-NC) Thomas Hawk

    ” If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him.”
    — Cardinal De Richelieu

    There are over 12,000 threads that come up in the Flickr Help Forum for the search term “deleted” What is wrong with this picture?

    Flickr users deserve due process before our accounts are deleted without warning.

    I already knew I wasn’t the first user to be deleted and I’m really happy we all could create such a huge media response to force Flickr into actually recreating a deleted user account, and I am really, really thankful to everyone, who wrote something about this event or forwarded the news to others.

    I can’t say this often enough: THANK YOU ALL!

    But 12,000 “Deleted” threads on a user forum isn’t something to accept at all. My account with about 3.500 photos in it wasn’t that big, but I did some numbers of how long it would take me to restore only the organizational part of my account. Without the links, community discussions and contacts. After all I know project calculations, since this is part of my day job.

    I estimated roughly an hour for each picture to upload, add tags, titles, geo information, descriptions, adding it to sets and groups. From my experience this number will vary, depending on the topic of the photo. In the end I came up with a total of 425 man days (8h work day, Mon-Fri), meaning it would have taken me almost 2 years if I had the time to spend 8h a day to recreate the account. And keep in mind, I still have to work at least 8h a day for my normal job.

    Factoring this to the 10,000 oder 20,000 photos some of these people had in their accounts, it’s something you can’t repair at all. Spending more than 1 month to recreate your own account doesn’t make sense, even If you are a professional photographer, because you would be losing to much time you would normally be spending on earning money for a living.

    It is actually good, that there now is a “proven” way to get this accounts back, but it still needs some work. It also came far too late. After all Flickr has been around for 6 years now. So if Yahoo! and Flickr really want to make me happy with their service again, they should start by implementing safe guard to avoid deleting user accounts “by accident” instead of giving everyone free Pro memberships.

    Because honstly I didn’t actually pay for my Pro account over the last few months either. Receiving a free subscription is as easy as participating in some photography events, show up at meetings and photowalks, submit some of your work to competitions or visiting photography or web community related tradeshows. Talk to some people and here you are: 2-12 month free Flickr Pro subscription. Knowing this now I wonder if I would have actually paid for the first 4 years of my membership.

    History of Events

    You have to be fucking kidding, Yahoo!

    Thomas Hawk Digital Connection » Did Flickr “Accidentally” Delete Mirco Wilhelm’s Account?

    Flicker Account SNAFU Round Up - Day 2

    Made it to today’s local newspaper

    Posted via email from bindermichious | Comment »

  3. You have to be fucking kidding, Yahoo!

    Today I was a bit surprised when trying to log into my Flickr account. It didn’t remember I was logged in, but asked me for my password, knowing who I am. Then I was asked to “create” a Flickr account.

    Strange, because I already had an account … for the last 5 years with about 4000 pictures in it!

    The it came to me. I did report on a user account that had added me as a contact on sunday only containing obviously stolen material and complaints about having an older deleted account with similar content.

    I checked the email I received from the Flickr staff. It only stated, that the account will be checked for irregulations, so I asked if they, by mistake had deleted my account.

    Well, it turned out, they actually had:

    Normal 0 21 false false false DE X-NONE X-NONE

    Hello,

    Unfortunately, I have mixed up the accounts and accidentally deleted yours. I am terribly sorry for this grave error and hope that this mistake can be reconciled. Here is what I can do from here:

    I can restore your account, although we will not be able to retrieve your photos. I know that there is a lot of history on your account—again, please accept my apology for my negligence. Once I restore your account, I will add four years of free Pro to make up for my error.

    Please let me know if there’s anything else I can do.
    Again, I am deeply sorry for this mistake.

    Regards,

    Flickr staff

    It is kind of nice, getting an additional 4 years of service subscription for free… but I already received free Pro subscriptions for the next year just by taking part in some events and competitions.

    So how can this really compensate losing close to 4000 “linked” pictures from my web albums? I have to recreate most of these links manually, which will take weeks, if not months of my free time! Not to mention, external websites that had linked these images (including some official Yahoo! and Flickr blogs).

    In my day job I actually work as an IT Architect. I do designs on complex infrastructures, delivery processes and related stuff. Going from an activ account to a deleted account is pretty much a NO-GO in any enterprise environment, because of these consequences. If you do something wrong your can’t undo it again, without recreating every single setting from scratch.

    That’s why it’s VERY common to first “DEACTIVATE” accounts and repeat an evaluation… in this case: Me noticing a problem and contacting support to fix it.

    Since Flickr had deleted the account an all the related object, they cannot reactivate anything more that the account itself, leaving me with an empty shell of what I did during the last 5 years. This would be acceptable, if I had a free account. But since I’m a paying customer, I would expect a bit more that a “Again, I am deeply sorry for this mistake.”

    I expect at least a process that can undo this kind of mistakes. For any other kind of compensation, I will take some time to consult.

    Posted via email from bindermichious | Comment »

  4. You have to be fucking kidding!

    Hello,

    Unfortunately, I have mixed up the accounts and accidentally deleted yours. I am terribly sorry for this grave error and hope that this mistake can be reconciled.

    Here is what I can do from here:

    I can restore your account, although we will not be able to retrieve your photos. I know that there is a lot of history on your account—again, please accept my apology for my negligence. Once I restore your account, I will add four years of free Pro to make up for my error.

    Please let me know if there’s anything else I can do.

    Again, I am deeply sorry for this mistake.

    Regards,

    Flickr staff